• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Jim Johnston's Steak House – Premier Steak and Prime Rib Dining in Roseland, NJ

Jim Johnston's Steak House in Roseland, NJ, is a timeless gem known for its expertly cooked steaks, prime rib, and lamb chops that consistently impress with tenderness and flavor. The warm, welcoming atmosphere—whether at the bustling bar or cozy dining room—invites guests to relax and savor quality food alongside a wide selection of beers on tap. Service here is attentive and friendly, with bartenders delivering perfect martinis and servers who add a hometown touch. This steakhouse has stood the test of time, delivering exceptional taste and a sense of community, making each visit a memorable experience for both longtime patrons and newcomers alike.

Jim Johnston's Steak House at a glance

  • Address 58 Eisenhower Pkwy, Roseland, NJ 07068, United States
  • Phone +1 973-228-2457
  • Restaurant type Steak house , Bar & grill .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Jim Johnston's Steak House: Reviews & Ratings

Enzo Ferrara
5

One of my personal favorite restaurants around. The food and service have always been exceptional! It’s a nice environment whether you sit in the bar room or dining area. Wide variety of beers on tap.

Jeffrey Siegel
5

I was there with a family of like minded woodturners to reminisce about each other. We listened to stories of yesteryear and planned some future events. What a great bunch of people,Especially Mr Bob.

Matthew Rodwick
5

Have not been here for years, and very pleased to say things are just as good as they were 20 years ago. The bartender was fantastic and drinks especially the martinis were perfect. We had steaks, lamb chops and grilled chopped salad and they were cooked to perfection. It is nice to see the quality of service and food has stood the test of time and will definitely be back for more.

April Leaver
5

I have been doing a prime rib tour of the area for the past year. Gotta say, they have taken the lead. Excellent taste, tenderness, cooked to temperature, well priced. And they have it available every Friday and Saturday. Our server, Mandy, really knows how to hustle. It was quite busy. Hometown feeling where many know each other.

Anthony DeVincenzo (ArtisticSignsLLC)
5

Was there a few weeks ago. Haven't been in a while but everything was great. Sat at the bar and just wanted a few drinks and burger. Came out just as I wanted it. Looking to make another trip over soon. Thank you

nick eucker
5

This place is a gem. Old school steak house with impeccable service and great food! The atmosphere is something to treasure rather than critique. Our table ordered 3 steaks(2 Filets, 1 NY Strip) and 1 chicken pot pie. All 3 steaks were cooked to perfection and the pot pie is something we all will crave! Looking forward to our next meal here.

Patricia Yackshaw
4

Driving thru from Newark airport. Got the Reuben. It didn't list that the sandwich was open-faced which was disappointing and the Russian dressing mixed in with the sauerkraut was overwhelming and needed to be scraped off. I would suggest putting it on the side as I've never had an issue with Russian dressing when ordering elsewhere. I opted out of the fries and asked for a salad which the bartender 'forgot' to tell me was an upcharge when I showed her the price discrepancy on the menu. Seems like a nice little local hangout.

Location

  • Jim Johnston's Steak House
    Jim Johnston's Steak House
    58 Eisenhower Pkwy, Roseland, NJ 07068, United States Hotline: +1 973-228-2457

Nestled in the heart of Roseland, New Jersey, Jim Johnston's Steak House stands as a timeless beacon for steak lovers and those who appreciate hearty, well-crafted meals. With a legacy that spans decades, this establishment consistently delivers an experience where tradition meets exceptional quality.

Customers frequently praise the impeccable service and the inviting atmosphere that strikes a fine balance between casual and refined. Whether seated in the bustling bar room or the comfortable dining area, guests are treated to more than just a meal—they’re welcomed into a community. The bar offers an impressive array of beers on tap, complementing the crafted cocktails, notably the perfectly balanced martinis that many return for.

What truly distinguishes Jim Johnston's is its mastery over classic dishes—the steaks, lamb chops, and grilled chopped salads come cooked to flawless perfection, satisfying both the palate and the eye. The prime rib, available every Friday and Saturday, garners particular acclaim for its tenderness, flavor, and spot-on temperature, showcasing the kitchen's dedication to quality and consistency.

Beyond the food, there’s a hometown charm where servers like Mandy infuse genuine care into each interaction, making even the busiest nights run smoothly. This blend of culinary mastery and warm hospitality has earned Jim Johnston's a revered spot in patrons’ hearts, creating memories that span generations.

For anyone seeking a dining experience rooted in tradition, quality, and a sense of belonging, Jim Johnston's Steak House is a destination not to be missed. It’s more than a restaurant—it’s a return to heartfelt, honest dining done right.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards